It is not hard to find historical causes for this disassociated sensibility in the United States. World War II itself, the rise of anonymity and consumerism in a mass urban society, the protest movements of the 1960s, the decade-long Vietnam conflict, the Cold War, environmental threats -- the catalog of shocks to American culture is long and varied. The change that has most transformed American society, however, has been the rise of the mass media and mass culture. First radio, then movies, and now an all-powerful, ubiquitous television presence have changed American life at its roots. From a private, literate, elite culture based on the book, the eye, and reading, the United States has become a media culture attuned to the voice on the radio, the music of compact discs and cassettes, film, and the images on the television screen.
American poetry has been directly influenced by mass media and electronic technology. Films, videotapes, and tape recordings of poetry readings and interviews with poets have become available, and new inexpensive photographic methods of printing have encouraged young poets to self-publish and young editors to begin literary magazines -- of which there are now well over 2,000. From the late 1950s to the present, Americans have been increasingly aware that technology, so useful in itself, presents dangers through the wrong kinds of striking images. To Americans seeking alternatives, poetry seems more relevant than before: It offers people a way to express subjective life and articulate the impact of technology and mass society on the individual.
A host of styles, some regional, some associated with famous schools or poets, vie for attention; contemporary American poetry is decentralized, richly varied, and impossible to summarize. For the sake of discussion, however, it can be arranged along a spectrum, producing three overlapping camps -- the traditional on one end, the idiosyncratic in the middle, and the experimental on the other end. Traditional poets have maintained or revitalized poetic traditions. Idiosyncratic poets have used both traditional and innovative techniques in creating unique voices. Experimental poets have courted new cultural styles.
TRADITIONALISM
T
raditional writers include acknowledged masters of traditional
forms and diction who write with a readily recognizable craft,
often using rhyme or a set metrical pattern. Often they are from
the U.S. Eastern seaboard or from the southern part of the
country, and teach in colleges and universities. Richard Eberhart
and Richard Wilbur; the older Fugitive poets John Crowe Ransom,
Allen Tate, and Robert Penn Warren; such accomplished younger
poets as John Hollander and Richard Howard; and the early Robert
Lowell are examples. They are established and frequently
anthologized.
The previous chapter discussed the refinement, respect for
nature, and profoundly conservative values of the Fugitives.
These qualities grace much poetry oriented to traditional modes.
Traditionalist poets are generally precise, realistic, and witty;
like Richard Wilbur (1921- ), they are often influenced in these
directions by 15th- and 16th-century British metaphysical poets
brought to favor by T.S. Eliot. Wilbur's most famous poem, "A
World Without Objects Is a Sensible Emptiness" (1950), takes its
title from Thomas Traherne, a metaphysical poet. Its vivid
opening illustrates the clarity some poets have found within
rhyme and formal regularity:
Traditional poets, unlike many experimentalists who distrust
"too poetic" diction, welcome resounding poetic lines. Robert
Penn Warren (1905-1989) ended one poem with the words "To love so
well the world that we may believe, in the end, in God." Allen
Tate (1899-1979) ended a poem, "Sentinel of the grave who counts
us all!" Traditional poets also at times use a somewhat
rhetorical diction of obsolete or odd words, using many
adjectives (for example, "sepulchral owl") and inversions, in
which the natural, spoken word order of English is altered
unnaturally. Sometimes the effect is noble, as in the line by
Warren; other times, the poetry seems stilted and out of touch
with real emotions, as in Tate's line: "Fatuously touched the
hems of the hierophants."
Occasionally, as in Hollander, Howard, and James Merrill
(1926- ), self-conscious diction combines with wit, puns, and
literary allusions. Merrill, who is innovative in his urban
themes, unrhymed lines, personal subjects, and light
conversational tone, shares a witty habit with the
traditionalists in "The Broken Heart" (1966), writing about a
marriage as if it were a cocktail:
Obvious fluency and verbal pyrotechnics by some poets, like
Merrill and John Ashbery, make them successful in traditional
terms, although their poetry redefines poetry in radically
innovative ways. Stylistic gracefulness makes some poets seem
more traditional than they are, as in the case of Randall Jarrell
(1914-1965) and A.R. Ammons (1926- ). Ammons creates intense
dialogues between humanity and nature; Jarrell steps into the
trapped consciousness of the dispossessed -- women, children,
doomed soldiers, as in "The Death of the Ball Turret Gunner"
(1945):
Although many traditional poets use rhyme, not all rhymed
poetry is traditional in subject or tone. Poet Gwendolyn Brooks
(1917- ) writes of the difficulties of living -- let alone
writing -- in urban slums. Her "Kitchenette Building" (1945) asks
how:
Many poets, including Brooks, Adrienne Rich, Richard Wilbur,
Robert Lowell, and Robert Penn Warren began writing
traditionally, using rhyme and meters, but abandoned these in the
1960s under the pressure of public events and a gradual trend
toward open forms.
Robert Lowell (1917-1977)
Lowell fits the mold of the academic writer: white, male,
Protestant by birth, well-educated, and linked with the political
and social establishment. He was a descendant of the respected
Boston Brahmin family that included the famous 19th-century poet
James Russell Lowell and a recent president of Harvard
University. Robert Lowell found an identity outside his elite
background, however. He went not to Harvard but to Kenyon College
in Ohio, where he rejected his Puritan ancestry and converted to
Catholicism. Jailed for a year as a conscientious objector in
World War II, he later publicly protested the Vietnam conflict.
Lowell's early books, Land of Unlikeness (1944) and
Lord
Weary's Castle (1946), which won a Pulitzer Prize, revealed
great
control of traditional forms and styles, strong feeling, and an
intensely personal yet historical vision. The violence and
specificity of the early work is overpowering in poems like
"Children of Light" (1946), a harsh condemnation of the Puritans
who killed Indians and whose descendants burned surplus grain
instead of shipping it to hungry people. Lowell writes: "Our
fathers wrung their bread from stocks and stones / And fenced
their gardens with the Redman's bones."
Lowell's next book, The Mills of the Kavanaughs (1951),
contains moving dramatic monologues in which members of his
family reveal their tenderness and failings. As always, his style
mixes the human with the majestic. Often he uses traditional
rhyme, but his colloquialism disguises it until it seems like
background melody. It was experimental poetry, however, that gave
Lowell his breakthrough into a creative individual idiom.
On a reading tour in the mid-1950s, Lowell heard some of the
new experimental poetry for the first time. Allen Ginsberg's
Howl
and Gary Snyder's Myths and Texts, still unpublished, were
being
read and chanted, sometimes to jazz accompaniment, in coffee
houses in North Beach, a section of San Francisco. Lowell felt
that next to these, his own accomplished poems were too stilted,
rhetorical, and encased in convention; when reading them aloud,
he made spontaneous revisions toward a more colloquial diction.
"My own poems seemed like prehistoric monsters dragged down into
a bog and death by their ponderous armor," he wrote later. "I was
reciting what I no longer felt."
At this point Lowell, like many poets after him, accepted
the challenge of learning from the rival tradition in America --
the school of William Carlos Williams. "It's as if no poet except
Williams had really seen America or heard its language," he wrote
in 1962. Henceforth, Lowell changed his writing drastically,
using the "quick changes of tone, atmosphere and speed" that
Lowell most appreciated in Williams.
Lowell dropped many of his
obscure allusions; his rhymes became integral to the experience
within the poem instead of superimposed on it. The stanzaic
structure, too, collapsed; new improvisational forms arose. In
Life Studies (1959), he initiated confessional poetry, a
new mode
in which he bared his most tormenting personal problems with
great honesty and intensity. In essence, he not only discovered
his individuality but celebrated it in its most difficult and
private manifestations. He transformed himself into a
contemporary, at home with the self, the fragmentary, and the
form as process.
Lowell's transformation, a watershed for poetry after the
war, opened the way for many younger writers. In For the Union
Dead (1964), Notebook 1967-69 (1970), and later books,
he
continued his autobiographical explorations and technical
innovations, drawing upon his experience of psychoanalysis.
Lowell's confessional poetry has been particularly influential.
Works by John Berryman, Anne Sexton, and Sylvia Plath (the last
two his students), to mention only a few, are impossible to
imagine without Lowell.
IDIOSYNCRATIC POETS
P
oets who have developed unique styles drawing on tradition but
extending it into new realms with a distinctively contemporary
flavor, in addition to Plath and Sexton, include John Berryman,
Theodore Roethke, Richard Hugo, Philip Levine, James Dickey,
Elizabeth Bishop, and Adrienne Rich.
Sylvia Plath (1932-1963)
Plath's storybook life crumbled when she and Hughes
separated and she cared for the young children in a London
apartment during a winter of extreme cold. Ill, isolated, and in
despair, Plath worked against the clock to produce a series of
stunning poems before she committed suicide by gassing herself in
her kitchen. These poems were collected in the volume
Ariel
(1965), two years after her death. Robert Lowell, who wrote the
introduction, noted her poetry's rapid development from the time
she and Anne Sexton had attended his poetry classes in 1958.
Plath's early poetry is well-crafted and traditional, but her
late poems exhibit a desperate bravura and proto-feminist cry of
anguish. In "The Applicant" (1966), Plath exposes the emptiness
in the current role of wife (who is reduced to an inanimate
"it"):
It works, there is nothing wrong with it.
Plath dares to use a nursery rhyme language, a brutal
directness. She has a knack for using bold images from popular
culture. Of a baby she writes, "Love set you going like a fat
gold watch." In "Daddy," she imagines her father as the Dracula
of cinema: "There's a stake in your fat black heart / And the
villagers never liked you."
Anne Sexton (1928-1974)
The titles of her works indicate their concern with madness
and death. They include To Bedlam and Part Way Back
(1960), Live
or Die (1966), and the posthumous book The Awful Rowing
Toward
God (1975).
John Berryman (1914-1972)
Like his contemporary, Theodore Roethke, Berryman developed
a supple, playful, but profound style enlivened by phrases from
folklore, children's rhymes, clichés, and slang. Berryman
writes, of Henry, "He stared at ruin. Ruin stared straight back."
Elsewhere, he wittily writes, "Oho alas alas / When will
indifference come, I moan and rave."
Theodore Roethke (1908-1963)
Richard Hugo (1923-1982)
Philip Levine (1928- )
In one poem, Levine likens himself to a fox who survives in
a dangerous world of hunters through his courage and cunning. In
terms of his rhythmic pattern, he has traveled a path from
traditional meters in his early works to a freer, more open line
in his later poetry as he expresses his lonely protest against
the evils of the contemporary world.
James Dickey (1923- )
In the late 1960s, Dickey began working on a novel,
Deliverance, about the dark side of male bonding, which,
when
published and later filmed, increased his renown. His recent
collections of verse deal with such varied themes as the
landscape of the South (Jericho: The South Beheld, 1974)
and the
influence of the Bible on his life (God's Images, 1977).
Dickey
is often concerned with effort: "Outdoing, desperately / Outdoing
what is required."
Elizabeth Bishop (1911-1979) and Adrienne Rich (1929- )
With Moore, Bishop may be placed in a "cool" female poetic
tradition harking back to Emily Dickinson, in comparison with the
"hot" poems of Plath, Sexton, and Adrienne Rich. Though Rich
began by writing poems in traditional form and meter, her works,
particularly those written after she became an ardent feminist in
the 1960s, embody strong emotions. Her special genius is the
metaphor, as in her extraordinary work "Diving Into the Wreck"
(1973), evoking a woman's search for identity in terms of diving
down to a wrecked ship. The wreck is like the wreckage of women s
selfhood, the speaker suggests; women must find their way through
male-dominated realms. Rich's poem "The Roofwalker" (1961),
dedicated to poet Denise Levertov, imagines poetry writing, for
women, as a dangerous craft. Like men building a roof, she feels
"exposed, larger than life, / and due to break my neck."
EXPERIMENTAL POETRY
T
he force behind Lowell's mature achievement and much of
contemporary poetry lies in the experimentation begun in the
1950s by a number of poets. They may be divided into five loose
schools, identified by Donald Allen in his The New American
Poetry (1960), the first anthology to present the work of
poets
who were previously neglected by the critical and academic
communities.
Inspired by jazz and abstract expressionist painting, most
of the experimental writers are a generation younger than Lowell.
They have tended to be bohemian, counter-culture intellectuals
who disassociated themselves from universities and outspokenly
criticized "bourgeois" American society. Their poetry is daring,
original, and sometimes shocking. In its search for new values,
it claims affinity with the archaic world of myth, legend, and
traditional societies such as those of the American Indian. The
forms are looser, more spontaneous, organic; they arise from the
subject matter and the feeling of the poet as the poem is
written, and from the natural pauses of the spoken language. As
Allen Ginsberg noted in "Improvised Poetics," "first thought best
thought."
The Black Mountain School
Robert Creeley (1926- ), who writes with a terse,
minimalist style, was one of the major Black Mountain poets. In
"The Warning" (1955), Creeley imagines the violent, loving
imagination:
Love is dead in us
The San Francisco School
San Francisco poets include Jack Spicer, Lawrence
Ferlinghetti, Robert Duncan, Phil Whalen, Lew Welch, Gary Snyder,
Kenneth Rexroth, Joanne Kyger, and Diane diPrima. Many of these
poets identify with working people. Their poetry is often simple,
accessible, and optimistic.
At its best, as seen in the work of Gary Snyder (1930- ),
San Francisco poetry evokes the delicate balance of the
individual and the cosmos. In Snyder's "Above Pate Valley"
(1955), the poet describes working on a trail crew in the
mountains and finding obsidian arrowhead flakes from vanished
Indian tribes:
Beat Poets
Beat poetry was the most anti-establishment form of
literature in the United States, but beneath its shocking words
lies a love of country. The poetry is a cry of pain and rage at
what the poets see as the loss of America's innocence and the
tragic waste of its human and material resources.
Poems like Allen Ginsberg's Howl (1956) revolutionized
traditional poetry:
The New York School
The major figures of the New York School -- John Ashbery,
Frank O'Hara, and Kenneth Koch -- met while they were
undergraduates at Harvard University. They are quintessentially
urban, cool, nonreligious, witty with a poignant, pastel
sophistication. Their poems are fast moving, full of urban
detail, incongruity, and an almost palpable sense of suspended
belief.
New York City is the fine arts center of America and the
birthplace of Abstract Expressionism, a major inspiration of this
poetry. Most of the poets worked as art reviewers or museum
curators, or collaborated with painters. Perhaps because of their
feeling for abstract art, which distrusts figurative shapes and
obvious meanings, their work is often difficult to comprehend, as
in the later work of John Ashbery (1927- ), perhaps the most
influential poet writing today.
Ashbery's fluid poems record thoughts and emotions as they
wash over the mind too swiftly for direct articulation. His
profound, long poem, Self-Portrait in a Convex Mirror
(1975),
which won three major prizes, glides from thought to thought,
often reflecting back on itself:
Surrealism and Existentialism
Although T.S. Eliot, Wallace Stevens, and Ezra Pound had
introduced symbolist techniques into American poetry in the
1920s, surrealism, the major force in European poetry and thought
in Europe during and after World War II, did not take root in the
United States. Not until the 1960s did surrealism (along with
existentialism) become domesticated in America under the stress
of the Vietnam conflict.
During the 1960s, many American writers -- W.S. Merwin,
Robert Bly, Charles Simic, Charles Wright, and Mark Strand, among
others -- turned to French and especially Spanish surrealism for
its pure emotion, its archetypal images, and its models of anti-
rational, existential unrest.
Surrealists like Merwin tend to be epigrammatic, as in lines
such as: "The gods are what has failed to become of us / If you
find you no longer believe enlarge the temple."
Bly's political surrealism harshly criticized American
values and foreign policy during the Vietnam era in poems like
"The Teeth Mother Naked at Last":
The more pervasive surrealist influence has been quieter and
more contemplative, like the poem Charles Wright describes in
"The New Poem" (1973):
Mark Strand's surrealism, like Merwin's, is often bleak; it
speaks of an extreme deprivation. Now that traditions, values,
and beliefs have failed him, the poet has nothing but his own
cavelike soul:
Father Time and Mother Earth,
A marriage on the rocks.
And I hunched in its belly till my wet fur froze.
Six miles from earth, loosed from its dream of life,
I woke to black flak and the nightmare fighters.
When I died they washed me out of the turret with a hose.
Its white and violet, fight with fried potatoes
And yesterday's garbage ripening in the hall...
The most influential recent poet, Robert Lowell, began
traditionally but was influenced by experimental currents.
Because his life and work spans the period between the older
modernist masters like Ezra Pound and the contemporary writers,
his career places the later experimentalists in a larger context.
Sylvia Plath lived an outwardly exemplary life, attending
Smith College on scholarship, graduating first in her class, and
winning a Fulbright grant to Cambridge University in England.
There she met her charismatic husband-to-be, poet Ted Hughes,
with whom she had two children and settled in a country house in
England. Beneath the fairy-tale success festered unresolved
psychological problems evoked in her highly readable novel The
Bell Jar (1963). Some of these problems were personal, while
others arose from repressive 1950s attitudes toward women. Among
these were the beliefs -- shared by most women themselves -- that
women should not show anger or ambitiously pursue a career, and
instead find fulfillment in tending their husbands and children.
Successful women like Plath lived a contradiction.
It can sew, it can cook.
It can talk, talk, talk.
You have a hole, it's a poultice.
You have an eye, it's an image.
My boy, it's your last resort.
Will you marry it, marry it, marry it.
Like Plath, Anne Sexton was a passionate woman who attempted to
be wife, mother, and poet on the eve of the women's movement in
the United States. Like Plath, she suffered from mental illness,
and ultimately committed suicide. Sexton's confessional poetry is
more autobiographical than Plath's and lacks the craftedness
Plath's earlier poems exhibit. Sexton's poems appeal powerfully
to the emotions, however. They thrust taboo subjects such as sex,
guilt, and suicide into close focus. Often they daringly
introduce female topics such as childbearing, the female body, or
marriage seen from a female point of view. In poems like "Her
Kind" (1960), Sexton identifies with a witch burned at the stake:
waved my nude arms at villages going by,
learning the last bright routes, survivor
where your flames still bite my thigh
and my ribs crack where your wheels wind.
A woman like that is not ashamed to die.
I have been her kind.
John Berryman's life parallels Robert Lowell's in some
respects. Born in Oklahoma, he was educated in the Northeast --
at prep school and at Columbia University, and later was a fellow
at Princeton University. Specializing in traditional forms and
meters, he was inspired by early American history and wrote self-
critical, confessional poems in his Dream Songs (1969),
which
feature a grotesque autobiographical character named Henry and
reflections on his own teaching routine, chronic alcoholism, and
ambition.
The son of a greenhouse owner, Theodore Roethke evolved a special
language evoking the "greenhouse world" of tiny insects and
unseen roots: "Worm, be with me. / This is my hard time." His
love poems in Words for the Wind (1958) celebrate beauty
and
desire with innocent passion: One poem begins "I knew a woman,
lovely in her bones, / When small birds sighed, she would sigh
back at them." Sometimes his poems seem like nature's shorthand
or ancient riddles: "Who stunned the dirt into noise? / Ask the
mole, he knows."
Richard Hugo, a native of Seattle, Washington, studied under
Theodore Roethke. He grew up poor in dismal urban environments
and excelled at communicating the hopes, fears, and frustrations
of working people against the backdrop of the northwestern United
States. Hugo wrote nostalgic, confessional poems in bold iambics
about shabby, forgotten small towns in his part of the United
States; he wrote of shame, failure, and rare moments of
acceptance through human relationships. He focused the reader's
attention on minute, seemingly inconsequential details in order
to make more significant points. "What Thou Lovest Well, Remains
American" (1975) ends with a person carrying memories of his old
hometown as if they were food:
empty town
and need hungry lovers for friends,
and need feel
you are welcome in the street club
they have formed.
Philip Levine, born in Detroit, Michigan, deals directly with
the
economic sufferings of workers through keen observation, rage,
and painful irony. Like Hugo, his background is urban and poor.
He has been the voice for the lonely individual caught up in
industrial America. Much of his poetry is somber and reflects an
anarchic tendency amid the realization that systems of government
will endure.
James Dickey, a novelist and essayist as well as poet, is a
native of Georgia. By his own reflection, he believes that the
major theme in his work is the continuity that exists -- or must
exist -- between the self and the world. Much of his writing is
rooted in nature -- rivers and mountains, weather patterns, and
the perils lurking within.
Among women poets of the idiosyncratic group, Elizabeth Bishop
and Adrienne Rich have garnered the most respect in recent years.
Bishop's crystalline intelligence and interest in remote
landscapes and metaphors of travel appeal to readers for their
exactitude and subtlety. Like her mentor Marianne Moore, Bishop,
who never married, wrote highly crafted poems in a cool,
descriptive style that contains hidden philosophical depths. The
description of the ice-cold North Atlantic in "At the Fishhouses"
could apply to Bishop's own poetry: "It is like what we imagine
knowledge to be: / dark, salt, clear, moving, utterly free."
The Black Mountain School centered around Black Mountain College
an experimental liberal arts college in Asheville, North
Carolina, where poets Charles Olson, Robert Duncan, and Robert
Creeley taught in the early 1950s. Ed Dorn, Joel Oppenheimer, and
Jonathan Williams studied there, and Paul Blackburn, Larry
Eigner, and Denise Levertov published work in the school's
magazines, Origin and the Black Mountain Review.
The Black
Mountain School is linked with Charles Olson's theory of
"projective verse," which insisted on an open form based on the
spontaneity of the breath pause in speech and the typewriter line
in writing.
split open your head and put
a candle in
behind the eyes.
if we forget
the virtues of an amulet
and quick surprise
The work of the San Francisco School -- which includes most
West Coast poetry in general -- owes much to Eastern philosophy
and religion, as well as to Japanese and Chinese poetry. This is
not surprising because the influence of the Orient has always
been strong in the U.S. West. The land around San Francisco --
the Sierra Nevada Mountains and the jagged seacoast -- is lovely
and majestic, and poets from that area tend to have a deep
feeling for nature. Many of their poems are set in the mountains
or take place on backpacking trips. The poetry looks to nature
instead of literary tradition as a source of inspiration.
A land of fat summer deer,
They came to camp. On their
Own trails. I followed my own
Trail here. Picked up the cold-drill,
Pick, singlejack, and sack
Of dynamite.
Ten thousand years.
The San Franciso School blends into the next grouping -- the
"Beat" poets, who emerged in the 1950s. Most of the important
Beats (beatniks) migrated to San Francisco from the East Coast,
gaining their initial national recognition in California. Major
Beat writers have included Allen Ginsberg, Gregory Corso, Jack
Kerouac, and William Burroughs. Beat poetry is oral, repetitive,
and immensely effective in readings, largely because it developed
out of poetry readings in underground clubs. Some might correctly
see it as a great-grandparent of the rap music that became
prevalent in the 1990s.
Unlike the Beat and San Franciso poets, the poets of the New York
School are not interested in overtly moral questions, and, in
general, they steer clear of political issues. They have the best
formal educations of any group.
You are allowing extraneous matters
To break up your day...
In his anthology defining the new schools, Donald Allen includes
a fifth group he cannot define because it has no clear
geographical underpinning. This vague group includes recent
movements and experiments. Chief among these are surrealism,
which expresses the unconscious through vivid dreamlike imagery,
and much poetry by women and ethnic minorities that has
flourished in recent years. Though superficially distinct,
surrealists, feminists, and minorities appear to share a sense of
alienation from white, male, mainstream literature.
for smoked oysters
that bomb holes appear in the rice
paddies
It will not console our children.
It will not be able to help us.
So I open the door and walk in.
It is dark and I walk in.
It is darker and I walk in.
Outline of American Literature:
Contents